Then, more hateful instant messages popped up on the computer screen all hours of the night.
And last week, the Delaware Valley middle school student perpetrator
turned to cell phone text messages to continue bullying the classmate
she did not like.
The incident reflects a growing trend:
Bullies have moved from school grounds to cyberspace. Often cloaked in
anonymity, these "cyberbullies" use Internet and communication
technology to harass their victims.
Their goals, however, do not differ much from traditional, schoolyard bullies.
"They want to torment, intimidate, mock, frighten their victims," said
Ted Feinberg, assistant executive director of the National Association
of School Psychologists in Bethesda, Md. "The difference is the
technology is making it easier."
Just how widespread cyberbullying is remains unclear. There are few solid statistics about online harassment.
One study, conducted by the University of New Hampshire in 2000, found
that one in 17 youths has been threatened or harassed online. A 2002
study done in Great Britain by NCH, a children's charity, found one in
four students had been bullied online.
Kids who are shy are empowered by the technology, especially the anonymity surrounding it, Feinberg said. Many cyberbullies are former victims who use the technology to get back at their tormentors.
Technology is also making online harassment more pervasive and the
torment more vicious, said Nancy Willard, executive director of the
Oregon-based Center for Safe and Responsible Internet Use.
"There is a social norm among kids that when they are online, they have
free speech rights and can say anything they want about anyone else,"
she said.
For the Delaware Valley student being cyberbullied
by a classmate, the online harassment has escalated to ethnic slurs and
threats. The newspaper is withholding the names of the students
involved in the incident for safety reasons.
"My mom wants to talk to my teacher about it, but I don't want her to," the student said. "I don't want it to get worse."
Still, experts advise parents to bring cyberbullying incidents to the attention of school officials.
"Cyberbullying has an impact on students during the school day, even if
the online harassment happened off school premises," said Parry Aftab,
executive director of WiredSafety.org, a nonprofit organization with
experts on cyberbullying. "Parents should be contacting school
officials, their Internet service providers, even the police."
Internet service providers often have strict, zero-tolerance policies against online harassment, said Aftab, who is a lawyer.
Lackawanna County Judge Terrence R. Nealon ruled last year that AOL
Time Warner had to reveal the identities of its anonymous subscribers
who were sending harassing and offensive e-mails and instant messages
to a former Lackawanna County woman.
Getting serious
If the online harassment turns to threats of physical violence,
criminal charges can be filed. A civil case could also be filed for
defamation, invasion of personal privacy or intentional infliction of
emotional distress.
"Parents don't realize just how serious
cyberbullying can be," Willard said. "It can depress kids or even cause
them to commit suicide. That's right. Victims of cyberbullying are
killing themselves."
In 2003, a 13-year-old Vermont boy killed
himself after being tormented for months by cyberbullies. He had
threatened to commit suicide to get back at his harassers.
Other cyberbullying incidents nationwide range from the creation of
personal Web sites used to poke fun at victims to using camera phones
to take photographs of students, altering the images then e-mailing
them to entire student bodies. Weblogs, which are online journals, have
been used to expose secrets about classmates.
Locally, a dozen
people contacted the Times-Shamrock newspapers in a published request
seeking victims of cyberbullying. They ranged from victims harassed at
work to school-aged students to young adults cyberbullied by
ex-boyfriends.
A 19-year-old Lackawanna County woman has been
harassed online by her ex-boyfriend for more than a year. The newspaper
is withholding her name for safety reasons.
She had to change
her cell phone number several times because he would send harassing and
threatening text messages. She showed the newspaper copies of hundreds
of e-mails and instant messages he sent.
"I just want it to stop," she said.
Finding solutions
Local educational institutions are increasingly offering support and assistance for victims of cyberbullying. Research into the problem is growing, too.
Dr. Lee Sebastiani, of Marywood University's School of Continuing
Education, and graduate student Matt Spott recently surveyed 252
Luzerne County junior and senior high school students about Internet
use. The results, which will be included in Dr. Sebastiani's book,
"Building Character Online," found more than half of the students read
something in a chatroom, instant message or e-mail that made them
afraid or angry.
"Parents are not keeping up with technology,
and they're not paying attention to what their children are doing
online," Dr. Sebastiani said.
The university is planning to offer training classes for teachers and parents about online issues, she said.
Many parents focus on protecting their children from online sexual
predators and pornography yet are oblivious to their child's online
world, Aftab said.
Schools are in an awkward position, though,
because they are not legally able to discipline students who are
harassing classmates off school grounds.
"We try to provide support if we become aware of it," said Ed Kairis, principal at Abington Heights Middle School. "We encourage parents to monitor what their kids are doing on computers at home."
Charles Gahwiler, principal at South Scranton Intermediate School, said
once or twice a year a parent will come in to discuss nasty e-mails or
instant messages their child received at home.
"The parents
want me to discipline the other person, but we can't if it's something
that happened at the home," he said. "We do try to get the two students
to talk."
To better combat cyberbullying, Aftab suggests
schools give parents contracts to sign that allow school officials to
discipline cyberbullies, even when the online harassment occurs off
school premises. Several New York schools have such contracts, she said.
She also created a program called Teenangels that gives students
training in all aspects of online safety, privacy and security. The FBI
and local law enforcement agencies partake in the training. Once
trained, the students run programs in their schools to teach
classmates, teachers and parents about safe online practices.
"I'm looking to bring the program to Pennsylvania," she said. "There
seems to be a need there (in Northeastern Pennsylvania) for it."